Carrollton was laid out in 1830 on Choctaw land given over for a county seat. Union troops under John Croxton burned its first courthouse on April 5, 1865, and the second burned on November 16, 1876. The courthouse on the square went up in 1877 and 1878 and served until 1994.
People come to look at one pane in a north garret window, where a faint shape resembling a face shows from the street. The legend holds that it is Henry Wells, a freedman locked in the garret on a charge of burning the old courthouse, whose face was burned into the glass by lightning as a mob gathered outside. The record is harder. Wells was arrested in January 1878 after another man accused him of the fire; he was shot twice as he tried to run, confessed, likely under coercion, and died of his wounds days later, apparently before the garret windows were even installed. The legend grew in a county with one of the highest lynching counts in Alabama: at least fifteen Black people were lynched here between 1886 and 1917. On September 14, 1893, a white mob stormed the jail in Carrollton and shot to death Paul Archer, Will Archer, Emma Fair, Ed Guyton and Paul Hill in their cells while they awaited investigation on an accusation of burning a gin house. Two weeks earlier Joe Floyd had been lynched in the same town.
A sign points to the pane, and binoculars across the street bring it closer. The town stages a Face in the Window festival each fall.
The closest stops worth working into your route
Roadside plaques and monuments within a short detour