The Mill Creek Baptist congregation outgrew its first log building after the revival years, and in May 1804 its members voted for a meeting house fifty feet by thirty, shingled, with five windows and three doors, the builder to be paid in trade by subscription. What went up is a cross-shaped building of half-hewn logs with twelve outside corners, said to stand for the twelve apostles or the twelve tribes, and three doors for the Trinity. It had no fireplace. Worshippers warmed their feet in bags of heated soapstones and at a fire kept burning outside.
The name came from a quarrel. In 1809 the pastor, John Mulkey, was accused of heresy for leaning toward Barton Stone's new Christian movement, and about 150 of the 200 members went with him. From then on it was Old Mulkey. The congregation counted Black as well as white members, and it split again more than once before it stopped meeting about 1885.
The building has the original log walls, huge cross beams, peg-legged benches and a handmade pulpit; the roof and puncheon floor are replacements. In the churchyard lie fifteen soldiers of the Revolution and Hannah Boone Stewart Pennington, Daniel Boone's sister, whose first husband, John Stewart, was killed in the frontier wars over Kentucky. She died in 1828. The state keeps the site as a shrine, with picnic tables under the trees on about five acres; walk the graves with care.
The closest stops worth working into your route
Roadside plaques and monuments within a short detour