Owensboro barbecue means mutton, and the reason is wool. The city's tourism office traces the habit to the 1800s, when Daviess County farmers, many of them Welsh, raised sheep for fleece and cooked the old ones that could no longer be shorn. By the late 1800s slow-smoked mutton and burgoo, a thick stew of vegetables and shredded meat, were the center of Catholic parish picnics across the county, cheap and plentiful enough to feed a crowd from one pit. Owensboro still celebrates it each May with its International Bar-B-Q Festival.
Moonlite began around 1950 as a small place with about a dozen seats. In 1963 Hugh "Pappy" and Catherine Bosley, who both worked at local distilleries and were raising five children, sold their house to buy it. The family built it into a 325-seat restaurant with a long buffet and a catering business, and children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren have run it since; the founders died in 2003.
The mutton is smoked over hickory, served beside pork ribs, beef brisket and chicken from the same pits. The burgoo recipe was adapted from one cooked at a local parish picnic, and the cornbread and macaroni come from family recipes. Order the mutton first, even if you think you know barbecue; it is the one plate you cannot get in most of the country.
The closest stops worth working into your route
Roadside plaques and monuments within a short detour