Historical Marker
Vance-Carson Duel
Tuxedo, Henderson County · North Carolina
Erected by State Department of Archives and History, 1950
During the 1827 campaign Vance called Carson's father a Tory turncoat and Carson himself a coward, and the insult outlived the election. Vance wrote his will before the meeting and, by one account, never fired. He was the uncle of Zebulon Vance. Accounts differ on who issued the challenge and on which side of the state line the two men stood. Carson, whose family enslaved as many as sixty people at Pleasant Gardens, moved to Texas, signed its declaration of independence and constitution in 1836, and died at Hot Springs, Arkansas, in 1838.
What the plaque says
VANCE-CARSON DUEL On Nov. 5, 1827, Robert B. Vance, former N.C. Congressman, was fatally wounded in a duel by Samuel P. Carson, his successor. 1/2 mile S.E.
Where it stands
35.19691, -82.43477 · Directions
Worth the stop nearby
- Carl Sandburg Home (Connemara) — 5.2 miThe Flat Rock farm where Carl Sandburg wrote and Lilian Sandburg raised champion goats, first built in 1838 by an enslaver and Confederate treasury secretary.
- Nina Simone's Tryon — 11 miThe foothill town where Eunice Waymon was born in 1933, learned piano and refused to play until her parents got their front-row seats back.
- Caesars Head State Park — 12 miA granite cliff on the lip of the Blue Ridge Escarpment, with a long view across the Piedmont and the trail to 420-foot Raven Cliff Falls.
- Table Rock State Park — 19 miThe bare granite dome the Cherokee called the table of the Great Spirit, and the lodge, lakes and trails the CCC built beneath it in the 1930s.
More markers nearby
- Saluda Grade — 5.6 mi
- St. John in the Wilderness — 5.9 mi
- C. G. Memminger — 5.9 mi
- George Trenholm — 6.1 mi