Historical Marker
Hog Trial / Election Fight
McCarr, Pike County · Kentucky
Erected by Kentucky Historical Society and Kentucky Department of Highways, 2001
The hog trial is less certain than the feud's retellings suggest. No court record of it has been found, and accounts place it anywhere from 1873 to 1878. Feud researcher Tom Dotson has argued that a justice of the peace had no power to try hog stealing, a felony, and that Kentucky capped such juries at six, so the familiar jury of six Hatfields and six McCoys could not have sat. He accepts that a quarrel over a hog probably happened. Bill Staton, the witness kin to both families, was killed by Sam and Paris McCoy in June 1880.
What the plaque says
Hog Trial In 1873 Randolph McCoy accused Floyd Hatfield of stealing his hog. A trial followed, presided over by Reverend Anderson Hatfield, justice of the peace. To be fair, the jury consisted of six Hatfields and six McCoys. One witness, William Staton, stated he had seen Floyd mark the hog's ear. This resulted in Floyd's acquittal. Presented by Pikeville-Pike County Tourism. Election Fight In August 1882 an election was held near Jerry Hatfield's house. A fight broke out between Tolbert McCoy and Elias Hatfield. Tolbert's brothers joined in the fight as did Ellison Hatfield, who was stabbed and shot. He later died in West Virginia. The McCoy brothers were captured and killed in the "pawpaw tree" incident. Presented by Pikeville-Pike County Tourism.
Where it stands
37.58023, -82.18010 · Directions
Worth the stop nearby
- Dils Cemetery — 20 miPikeville's 1871 hillside cemetery, an early integrated burial ground, where Randolph and Sarah McCoy lie after the feud drove them off Blackberry Creek.
- Breaks Interstate Park — 21 miThe Russell Fork's five-mile gorge through Pine Mountain on the Kentucky-Virginia line, run by both states since 1954, reached from Elkhorn City on KY-80.
More markers nearby
- John Paul Riddle, 1901-1989 — 20 mi
- Effie Waller Smith — 20 mi
- Pikeville Collegiate Institute — 20 mi
- County Named, 1870 — 28 mi