Historical Marker
Fair-Rutherford House
Columbia, Richland County · South Carolina
Erected by Historic Columbia Foundation, the City of Columbia, and the S.C. Department of Transportation, 2011
William H. Rutherford was thirteen and almost certainly enslaved when the Civil War ended. A young man of his name and age appears in the 1870 census living in Columbia with the family of Edward Simmons, a servant to Robert Brown Elliott, the Black congressman. In 1878 Rutherford bought a lot on Winn, later Gregg, Street and built a house; the 1880 census lists him as a barber. His regalia trade bought this house as a rental in 1905; Carrie Rutherford kept buying and selling property after her husband died. A great-grandson later practiced dentistry next door.
What the plaque says
Fair-Rutherford House The Fair-Rutherford House, a Greek Revival cottage, stood here from ca. 1850 until it was demolished in 2004. Built for Dr. Samuel Fair, it passed through several owners before 1905, when William H. Rutherford (1852-1910) bought and enlarged it. Rutherford, an African-American businessman born a slave, taught school, then made lodge regalia and supplies and briefly co-owned a local cigar factory. Rutherford House The Rutherford House was built in 1924-25 for Carrie Rutherford, daughter-in-law of W.H. Rutherford. Her son Dr. Harry B. Rutherford, Jr. (1911-1980) and his wife Dr. Evaretta Sims Rutherford (1910-1978) were prominent educators, he as a teacher and principal and later a dean at Benedict College, and she as a professor and department chair at Benedict College and Howard University. The house was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1984.
Where it stands
34.00738, -81.02330 · Directions
Worth the stop nearby
- Mann-Simons Site — 0.7 miA downtown Columbia lot held by one Black family from at least 1843 until 1970, with the 1870s house and ghost frames of the buildings urban renewal took.
- South Carolina State House — 0.7 miThe granite capitol begun in 1855 by enslaved and immigrant stonecutters, still marked by Sherman's shells, where the Confederate battle flag came down in 2015.
- Modjeska Monteith Simkins House — 0.8 miThe Columbia cottage where the civil rights organizer Modjeska Monteith Simkins lived from 1932 until her death in 1992, and where Thurgood Marshall stayed.
- South Carolina State Museum — 1.5 miThe state's museum of history, art, science and natural history, inside the 1894 Columbia Mills, the first textile mill in the world run entirely on electricity.
More markers nearby
- "Chesnut Cottage" — steps away
- Alston House — steps away
- Gregg Street — 0.2 mi
- Wesley Methodist Church — 0.2 mi