Historical Marker
Dr. Elizur & Esther Butler: Missionaries to the Cherokees
Rome, Floyd County · Georgia
Erected by Georgia Historical Commission, 1957
Butler was arrested twice in 1831, first in March and again in July, when the Georgia Guard took him, Samuel Worcester and nine other missionaries and teachers. All eleven were convicted that September and sent to the penitentiary at Milledgeville. Nine accepted the pardons offered them and went free. Butler and Worcester refused, staying in prison so the Cherokee could carry the case to the Supreme Court. They won, and the court voided their convictions, but the ruling went unenforced, and within six years the army had driven the Cherokee west.
What the plaque says
Dr. Elizur & Esther Butler: Missionaries to the Cherokees Buried in the grave sixty feet south of this point is Esther Post Butler. Born in Connecticut on September 15, 1798, Esther Post married Dr. Elizur Butler, physician and minister, In October 1820. The Butlers were sent by the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions to Brainerd and then to Creek Path, before arriving at the Haweis Mission, near Rome, in 1826. Mrs. Butler died in 1829 after eight years of service to the Cherokees. Two years later Dr. Butler was arrested for residing in the Cherokee Nation without taking an oath of allegiance to the State of Georgia and obtaining a license from the Governor. Sentenced, with Samuel Worcester, to four years of hard labor in the State penitentiary at Milledgeville, he was pardoned by Governor Wilson Lumpkin in 1833, almost a year after the United States Supreme Court nullified the law under which missionaries were arrested. Upon his release, Dr. Butler returned to the Mission at Haweis, but was forced to move the following year. In addition to attending the Cherokees during the Removal, Dr. Butler served the missions at Red Clay, Park Hill, and Fairfield and the Cherokee Female Seminary prior to his death in Arkansas in 1857.
Where it stands
34.25167, -85.36306 · Directions
Worth the stop nearby
- Berry College and Oak Hill — 11 miMartha Berry's work school for mountain children, grown since 1902 into a college on more than 27,000 acres north of Rome, with her Oak Hill home and museum.
- Chieftains Museum / Major Ridge Home — 11 miThe Oostanaula River home of the Cherokee leader Major Ridge, who signed the Treaty of New Echota and was killed for it in 1839.
- Cornwall Furnace Park — 13 miThe best-preserved stone blast furnace of its period in Alabama, built for the Confederacy in 1862 by the Noble brothers of Rome with hundreds of hired-out enslaved laborers.
- Howard Finster's Paradise Garden — 18 miThe preacher-artist Howard Finster's garden of concrete, bicycle frames, Bible verses and found objects in Pennville, saved by Chattooga County in 2012.
More markers nearby
- Georgia School for the Deaf — 10 mi
- Floyd County — 11 mi
- Admiral John Henry Towers — 11 mi
- De Soto in Georgia — 11 mi