Frazier B. Baker was a schoolteacher at Effingham, a married father of six, when President William McKinley named him postmaster of Lake City in 1897. After the 1896 election McKinley's administration appointed hundreds of Black postmasters across the South, and Lake City, a railroad town with fewer than a dozen Black residents, had never had one.
The petitions
White residents boycotted the office and petitioned for Baker's removal. Letters warned him to leave town, and shots were fired at him. One complaint held that he had cut mail delivery from three times a day to once; he had made the cut after threats against his life. Postal inspectors found the complaints unfounded. When an inspector recommended closing the office, a mob burned it, and historians say the arsonists expected no one would rent space for a post office while Baker held the job. The government found a building on the edge of town, and in February 1898 Baker brought his family to live there, in rooms that also served as the post office.
February 22, 1898
At about one in the morning the family woke to find the house on fire. Baker sent his son Lincoln for help, and gunfire met the boy at the door. As the heat rose, Lavinia Baker carried their youngest child, Julia, toward the door, and a bullet killed the baby in her arms. Baker was shot down in the doorway. Lavinia was wounded. Rosa, 18, had her arm broken by a bullet, Cora, 14, was shot in the hand and Lincoln, 11, was shot in the abdomen. Sarah and Millie were unhurt. The survivors hid in a field across the road and went three days without medical care. On February 24 the Kingstree County Record called the killings "one of the most brutal and horrible deeds that has ever occurred in this State."
Charleston and after
A county grand jury indicted no one. Postal inspectors and the federal district attorney took up the case. Ida B. Wells-Barnett met the president, pressed the killing as a federal matter and asked Congress to aid the family; Congress did not act. Senator Benjamin Tillman defended the lynching. In April 1899 thirteen men were indicted in federal court in Charleston, on counts that included conspiracy to oppress Baker in the exercise of his civil rights and destruction of the mail. Two turned state's evidence, and Joseph Newham testified that he had started the fire. The all-white jury acquitted three men and deadlocked on the rest. The judge declared a mistrial, and the case was never retried.
Lavinia Baker and five surviving children moved to Boston, where William Lloyd Garrison Jr. raised money for a house. Tuberculosis killed four of the children between 1908 and 1920. Lavinia came home to the Pee Dee and died in 1947. St. James AME Church was built on the site of the post office in 1918, and a state historical marker went up on South Church Street in 2013. In December 2018 Congress named the Lake City post office for Frazier Baker, and it was dedicated on February 22, 2019, 121 years after the fire.
Lake City also remembers another of its own at the Ronald E. McNair Life History Center, in the library the astronaut was refused as a boy.