Michael Donald was 19, the youngest son of Beulah Mae Donald. He was a technical college student and worked at the Mobile Press-Register. On the night of March 20, 1981, he went out to buy cigarettes for his sister. He had no criminal record and no connection to the trial that had angered Klansmen that week. His mother spent the rest of her life making the city, and then a federal jury, say who killed him and why.
The anger was over Josephus Anderson, a Black man charged with killing a white Birmingham police officer and tried in Mobile on a change of venue, whose jury could not agree. At a meeting of United Klans of America Unit 900, members blamed the Black jurors, and Bennie Jack Hays, a Klan leader, said in effect that if a Black man could get away with killing a white man, a white man should get away with killing a Black man.
Herndon Avenue
His son, Henry Hays, 26, and James "Tiger" Knowles, 17, drove out with a gun and a rope. They stopped Donald to ask directions, forced him into the car and drove to woods across the county line. They beat him, strangled him and cut his throat, then hung his body from a tree on Herndon Avenue, across from Hays's house, where it stayed until morning.
The investigation
Police first called it a drug killing and arrested three other men. His mother insisted her son had nothing to do with drugs, and tests found none in his body. She asked Jesse Jackson for help, and he led a protest march. The FBI was ready to close its file when Assistant U.S. Attorney Thomas Figures, whose brother Michael, a state senator, represented the family, won a second investigation. Figures worked with FBI agent James Bodman, and in 1983 Knowles confessed.
Knowles pleaded guilty to a federal civil rights charge and testified against the others; he was sentenced to life in 1985 and paroled in 2006. Henry Hays was convicted of capital murder, and the judge overrode the jury's vote for life and sentenced him to death. Benjamin Franklin Cox Jr., who supplied the rope, was convicted as an accomplice in 1989. Bennie Hays's trial for inciting the killing ended in a mistrial, and he died before a retrial.
Beulah Mae Donald's suit
Beulah Mae Donald wanted more than convictions. In 1984 Morris Dees of the Southern Poverty Law Center and Michael Figures filed a wrongful-death suit in her name in federal court at Mobile against the United Klans of America, arguing that the organization answered for what its members did. She turned down a $1 million settlement. On February 12, 1987, an all-white jury awarded her $7 million, the first time the Klan was held financially liable for its members' acts. The United Klans' two-story national headquarters was sold for $51,875, and the money went to her. She told the Klansmen she forgave them.
She died in Mobile on September 17, 1988, at 67. On June 6, 1997, Alabama executed Henry Hays, the state's first execution for a white man's killing of a Black person since 1913. In 2006 Mobile renamed Herndon Avenue for Michael Donald.